Cincinnati Financial management check

CINF · Financials · Property & Casualty Insurance · CEO Stephen M. Spray

Filings as of

71
Management score, ranked 164th of 487 · 31st of 72 in Financials4 good · 3 to watch · 0 flaggedStrongest: CEO cost · Weakest: owner returns · Best and worst run in Financials →

The seven checks

  • Watch

    Have owners done well?

    Trailed its chosen peersOwners$211Peers$222

    What $100 became since fiscal 2021

    4450th
    Detail

    $100 invested at the start of fiscal 2021 grew to $211, against $222 for the peer group the company picked itself.

  • Watch

    Does pay follow performance?

    Pay only loosely tracked returns20212025

    Pay actually paid $100 value, each on its own scale

    7334th
    Detail

    Over 5 years, the CEO's pay actually paid (equity valued at the share price) had a correlation of 0.46 with shareholder return. 1 means pay moved in step; below 0, the opposite way.

  • Good

    What does the CEO cost owners?

    0.2% of net income

    $5.9m pay · $2.4bn net income, FY2025

    0.1%1%3%10%
    100100th
    Detail

    $5.9m of reported pay in fiscal 2025, against $2.4bn of net income.

  • Good

    Do they own the stock?

    Insiders are buying

    17,741 shares

    6 mo: ▲ $172k bought · ▼ $1.3m sold

    8095th
    Detail

    1 insider bought $172k on the open market in the last six months, with their own money, near the lows. Sales: $1.3m.

  • Good

    Are owners being diluted?

    Share count shrinking2021 · 163m2025 · 158m

    Diluted shares −0.1% a year; flagged above +2%

    0%10%20%

    Stock pay 0.3% of revenue

    5238th
    Detail

    Diluted shares changed -0.1% a year over the last three fiscal years. Stock-based pay was 0.3% of revenue in the latest year.

  • Watch

    Is leadership stable?

    2 CEOs in the pay table

    7 filings under 8-K 5.02 in 3 years

    0101420+

    CEOs: Steven J. Johnston, Stephen M. Spray

    5025th
    Detail

    CEOs in the pay table: Steven J. Johnston, Stephen M. Spray. 7 filings under 8-K item 5.02 (officers or directors leaving or joining, or new pay arrangements) in the last 3 years.

  • Good

    Are the books clean?

    No red flags on file

    Since 2021

    • 0Restated
    • 0Auditor changes
    • 0Late filings
    • 010-K amended
    100100th
    Detail

    No restatements, auditor changes or late filings since 2021.

  • Reading the scores

    Each check scored 0–100 from its own figure. The tick is the Financials median; the ordinal is the share of ranked S&P 500 companies it matches or beats.

    Hover a chart for its figures. Detail has the full reading.

Pay versus performance

From the proxy statement filed March 18, 2026.

CEO pay as reportedActually paid ⓘWhat $100 becamePeer group the company chose
$0$8.1m$16.2m$10020212022202320242025$211$222

Pay tied most to VCR

Other key measures3-year TSR

Show the figures
Fiscal yearCEOCEO payActually paidOther executives (avg)$100 becamePeersNet income
2025Stephen M. Spray$5.9m$7.9m$3.0m$211$222$2.4bn
2024Steven J. Johnston$9.9m$16.2m$4.3m$182$203$2.3bn
2023—$8.4m$6.7m$4.0m$128$152$1.8bn
2022—$7.6m$4.7m$3.5m$123$137−$487.0m
2021—$6.5m$9.6m$3.2m$133$120$2.9bn

Insiders and the CEO's stakeBuying

President & CEO
Stephen M Spray
Shares held
17,741
Latest Form 4
Nov 13, 2026

1 insider bought $172k on the open market in the last six months, with their own money, near the lows. Sales: $1.3m.

Open-market trades by officers and directors since May 21, 2026.

  • BoughtDirk J DebbinkDirector$172kAug 25, 2026
  • SoldCharles Odell SchiffDirector$1.3mAug 3, 2026

Leadership and governance on file

20222023202420252026Leadership 8Votes 6
All 8 filings

Latest shareholder vote results: May 6, 2026, including the say-on-pay vote.

Where the money went

2021–2025: $3.2bn returned to owners in buybacks and dividends, 36% of net income, and $33.0m of pay in stock.

Net incomeBuybacksDividendsStock-based payDiluted shares
−$487.0m$1.2bn$3.0bn20212022202320242025Shares163m159m158m158m158m
Show the figures
Fiscal year20212022202320242025
Revenue$9.6bn$6.6bn$10.0bn$11.3bn$12.6bn
Net income$3.0bn−$487.0m$1.8bn$2.3bn$2.4bn
Stock-based pay$33.0m————
Buybacks$144.0m$410.0m$67.0m$126.0m$205.0m
Dividends$395.0m$423.0m$454.0m$490.0m$525.0m
Diluted shares163m159m158m158m158m

Educational only, not investment advice. Figures are as filed with the SEC: pay from the proxy's pay-versus-performance table, capital allocation from 10-K XBRL data, insider trades from Form 4s over the last six months, events from the last 5 years of filings. The peer group is the one the company chose. See the method.